Contact us with your California corporate & securities law questions (949) 353-6347 or Contact us here

If You Plan To Claim Demand Futility, You Had Best Not Make A Demand

Rule 23.1 of the Nevada Rules of Civil Procedure specifies the pleading and standing requirements for shareholder derivative actions.  Among other things, Rule 23.1 requires that a complaint "allege with particularity the efforts, if any, made by the plaintiff to obtain the action the plaintiff desires from the directors or comparable authority and, if necessary, from the shareholders or members, and the reasons for the plaintiff’s failure to obtain the action or for not making the effort".  In other words, a plaintiff must either allege that she made a demand on the corporation's board of directors or that the making of such a demand would be futile. 

In Meridian OHC Partners, LP v. Davis, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 125186, the plaintiff had filed a derivative action alleging breaches of fiduciary duty, abuse of control, gross mismanagement, and waste of corporate assets.  The complaint alleged that demand was futile.  There was a problem, however, because the plaintiff had previously filed a derivative action in Nevada state court alleging that it had made a demand and that the demand had been wrongfully refused.  After the Nevada state court judge dismissed the action, the plaintiff filed another derivative action in federal district court.  Judge Jill A. Otake ruled:

"Indeed, it is contradictory for Plaintiff to argue in this action that demand would be futile when it already presented a demand and asserted allegations about the demand in the Nevada action."

When a shareholder makes a demand on the board, it is conceding that disinterestedness of the board to consider the demand.  That concession, however, does not foreclose the shareholder from challenging a board's decision not to pursue the action demanded by the shareholder, but that would be a case of wrongful refusal and not demand futility.

Share on:

derivative action, derivative suit

ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING CALIFORNIA CORPORATE AND SECURITIES LAW? CONTACT US DIRECTLY

We offer expert advice with the intricacies of California law.

Our years of experience and expertise allow us to help clients navigate the business laws in California.

CONTACT US

ABOUT OUR AUTHOR

30172DBAB0084D3A8F39D7AF0A8E79BC.ashx Keith Paul Bishop
Partner at Allen Matkins
(949) 353-6328
 Contact me
Learn More About Keith

RECOGNITION
JD Supra Readers Choice Top Author 2020

NationalLawReview



nominee-badge

Get the latest news and analysis about California Corporate & Securities law. Subscribe to our newsletter today!

We respect your email privacy

CATEGORIES

see all

YOUTUBE

FACEBOOK